Wake mulling no take-home laptops for elementary students, other tech changes
×

Wake mulling no take-home laptops for elementary students, other tech changes

Posted: 11/17/2026, 11:23:05 PM

Changes could soon be coming for Wake elementary students' laptops.

The school system on Tuesday recommended that district students from kindergarten through fifth grade be barred from taking their Chromebooks home, starting next school year. The school principal could override that if they found that a particular assignment required students to be able to take them home.

It's one of a handful of changes the district is considering ahead of a new approach to technology leaders expect to rollout next month.

Ahead of that, the school board weighed in on the proposed changes during a work session Tuesday, largely supporting the changes but questioning why some of them would take so long.

The district is, so far, recommending:

  • Not allowing kindergarten through fifth-grade students to take home devices. The district would still issue a device to each student but expects to have to replace them less often because of reduced wear and tear, saving up to $14 million within three years.
    • Expanding its lower-technology pilot program, in which students aren't issued their own device, from one elementary school to five or eight more.
      • Piloting a tool that allows teachers to monitor students' web activity and control access to websites and apps in a handful of middle schools and a few high schools. Currently, the district controls access at the district level.
        • Adding accidental damage protection for middle school students' devices, which are more prone to damage
          • Looking at whether to not allow middle school students to take their devices home eventually

            Wake also plans to audit teachers' use of technology during the spring semester to see when teachers might not be using it effectively. It's also looking at providing more training to teachers.

            Board members weren't sure why the district needed so much time to study these things. Several asked if the district could accelerate the timeline of making changes, citing the demand from families and the need to save money -- or avoid future costs -- now.

            They also urged the district to scale up. Some board members suggested expanding the kindergarten-through-second-grade "low-tech" pilot -- in which students aren't issued their own devices and must share throughout the school -- to all elementary grades. The "low-tech" approach used to be common.

            "Do we really need to pilot something that we've always done before?" asked Board Member Cheryl Caulfield.

            Board Vice Chairman Sam Hershey wondered why the district needed to spend a year, starting next summer, studying whether middle school students should leave their devices at school and then another year planning for it.

            "Do we need 2.5 years to determine whether middle school students should keep devices at school?" he asked. "That's a long time."

            Schools haven't necessarily been eager to make the change, said Pam Batchelor, the district's senior director of digital learning and libraries. Some may use less technology than others, but Batchelor said only one elementary school, Highcroft Drive, was interested in the low-tech pilot, which provides half as many laptops as the school has students, rather than one laptop for each student. One goal of bringing on more students into the pilot program is to see how more schools across different parts of the county, serving different types of students, handle the changes, she said.

            "It's a lot for schools to take on," Batchelor said.

            Board Member Toshiba Rice noted that the district would need to rethink its homework approach if students can't take devices home. She then suggested avoiding giving homework to some students, citing their well-being. She said too many students don't get home until after 5 p.m. via the school bus.

            "We have to do better with taking care of our students," Rice said.

            Board members widely favored the idea of teachers being able to monitor students' web activity, particularly as class was going on.

            "It sounds like a game-changer," Board Member Lynn Edmonds said.

            But that comes with a cost, likely many thousands of dollars just for the pilot, district leaders said.

            That makes it extra critical that the board finds a way to pay for the technology by cost-cutting elsewhere, such as the $4.7 million they expect to save annually by making the elementary devices last longer, Board Chairman Tyler Swanson said.

            "My biggest concern is the budget," Swanson said. "I can't put another dollar into this knowing there's fiscal concerns."

            The school board and the district have been re-evaluating the district's approach to technology use in lessons after pushback from school board members and district families who question how much some students really need laptops to effectively learn. Some board members previously hoped the district could save money by cutting back laptop issuance to students, but district leaders have since balked at the idea that the district could reduce the number of laptops it bought.

            The pushback is even broader than Wake County, with other school districts in North Carolina and beyond recently choosing to pull back on technology use.

            Last month, Wake teacher surveys showed frustration among middle and high school teachers that technology was used too much and was too distracting. Data showed most students spent the most time on YouTube.