Buyer beware: Banned products found listed on secondhand marketplaces
×

Buyer beware: Banned products found listed on secondhand marketplaces

Posted: 11/16/2026, 11:35:30 PM

As families start their holiday shopping, browsing through resell apps can save some money. However, getting a deal could actually cost you in the long run, if you’re not careful. 

A Consumer Reports evaluation found dangerous – and even banned -- children’s products on online marketplaces.

CR evaluated four major platforms – Facebook Marketplace, eBay, Craigslist and Mercari – and found banned baby products on all four marketplaces. It’s illegal to sell recalled products, including on the secondhand market, but buyers and sellers may not understand the law, or even know if a product has been recalled.

CR’s investigation found unsafe products such as drop-side cribs, padded crib bumpers, infant inclined sleepers, and in-bed sleepers, with particularly troubling listings found on Facebook Marketplace.

CR’s evaluators stopped counting after finding 50 in-bed sleepers in 65 search results. These products have been connected to suffocation and asphyxiation risk and should not be used for infant sleep. 

“Money can be very tight, and if you're trying to save a few bucks by buying it secondhand, you just want to make sure that you are actually getting something that's worth the money that you are going to spend on it,” said Alyssa Parker with the Better Business Bureau of Eastern Carolinas.

She said buyers should do their research and ask questions before handing over any money. 

“Do your research on that specific item. Is it the actual item? Are the pictures being manipulated? You can ask the seller, being like, "Well, what is the exact manufacturer?”

Parker recommends buyers use credit cards and keep all communication within the resell platform. Taking those steps offers better protection in the event there is an issue with the order. 

“Typically, on a number of these different apps or sites, sellers have ratings,” Parker said. “Make sure that you're reading that and seeing [whether] past customers of this particular seller had good interactions, bad interactions? Has the item come quickly? Has the item seemed like what they're actually describing it as?”

In a statement to Consumer Reports, Meta said recalled products are prohibited by their policies, and that policies are enforced through both automated detection and human review.

CR’s advice for buying secondhand is to use the exact product name or model number to check recalls.gov for recalls and safety alerts. And if you’re selling, make sure the item hasn’t been recalled before posting it online. 

Consumer Reports says to be especially careful with used child car seats. A child car seat may look fine, but it could have hidden damage, be missing parts or labels, be past its expiration date, or have been in a crash. In most cases, child car seat experts say the safest thing to do is buy a new one.