Consumer Reports tests lipstick for heavy metals
×

Consumer Reports tests lipstick for heavy metals

Posted: 11/18/2026, 1:51:58 PM

Lead in lipstick is a familiar issue that made headlines 20 years ago, prompting Food and Drug Administration (FDA) testing and new industry guidelines. Has anything changed since then? Consumer Reports recently tested two dozen popular lipsticks for lead. Here’s what you need to know.

Lipstick is a cosmetic staple, and because it’s applied directly to the lips, it can be partially ingested, potentially exposing people to harmful ingredients. That’s why Consumer Reports tested 24 lipsticks from popular brands.

First, the good news: most had very low lead levels. The test results were reassuring. Some results were higher than others, but all of the lipsticks tested had pretty low levels of lead.

Consumer Reports tested top sellers, products marketed as “clean” and “natural,” and brands sold through online marketplaces. Consumer Reports selected true red shades when available.

All the lipsticks Consumer Reports tested had lead levels well below the FDA’s recommended limits, and many were at trace amounts.

There was a range, however. The highest level, while still low, was found in a less-than-$3 lipstick sold on Temu. After Consumer Reports contacted Temu, it removed the product from its site.

Also, price was not a predictor. The lowest lead levels came from a $6 E.L.F. lipstick, while Estée Lauder’s $44 lipstick had comparatively higher levels. Estée Lauder said that "lead and other heavy metals are never intentionally added as ingredients and that these elements occur naturally in the environment."

It’s hard to be an informed consumer when you’re shopping for cosmetics, because ‘clean’ is not a regulated term, and every company may be using it differently. Plus, lead isn’t an ingredient: it’s a contaminant.

Consumer Reports contacted the companies behind the lipsticks it tested. The Personal Care Products Council, a cosmetics and personal care products trade group, said its members’ products are “extensively tested and deemed safe in accordance with state and federal regulations.”

Consumer Reports’ advice: Stick with established brands that provide clear ingredient information, be skeptical of “clean” or “natural” claims, and consider reapplying less often.