Fact check: Jon Stewart claims Chuck Schumer opposed 'half' of Democratic Senate winners
×

Fact check: Jon Stewart claims Chuck Schumer opposed 'half' of Democratic Senate winners

Posted: 11/13/2026, 8:57:29 PM

Soon after Democrats retook the U.S. Senate, comedian Jon Stewart stirred the pot on his weekly podcast, criticizing Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., who could become his party’s majority leader in the coming weeks.

“One of the first things you need to do is remove that system of seniority from Democratic politics,” Stewart said Nov. 5, two days after the election. “It is a b——- system, and it needs to go. … (People are) already like, ‘Chuck Schumer deserves a lot of credit for putting together this (victory). … Enough. Chuck Schumer fought tooth and nail against half of these f—— people, and even if he didn’t, he does not understand the urgency of the moment and what the future demands.”

Stewart’s remark echoes the complaints of some progressives, who have criticized Schumer’s support for Rep. Haley Stevens over the more progressive Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan’s Senate primary race. El-Sayed won the general election, days after Stevens endorsed his opponent, Republican former Rep. Mike Rogers. Schumer also faces discontent from some Democrats who want a new generation of leadership; Schumer is 75 and has been in Congress since 1981.

Even when accounting for comedic hyperbole, Stewart ignores that Schumer actively recruited at least five of the winning Democratic Senate candidates — enough to supply the margin that flipped the chamber blue. Schumer did support an alternative candidate before the primary in three states, but he closed ranks once the nomination was settled.

In a Nov. 6 interview with The New York Times’ The Daily podcast, Schumer said he didn’t expect to face any challenge in the election for Senate majority leader. Schumer said: “Our caucus is focused on moving forward. Everyone’s very happy with what we all did.”

Michael Cohen, a Democratic commentator and MS NOW columnist, said he gives “most credit (for the Democrats flipping the Senate) to Donald Trump, but I would put Schumer second. He recruited these candidates.”

Representatives for Stewart did not respond to our inquiry. The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, which is the political arm of Senate Democrats aligned with Schumer, did not respond, either.

Which candidates did Schumer support from the beginning?

For the North Carolina race, Schumer recruited former Gov. Roy Cooper, who ended up winning by 20 points. As long ago as April 2025, Axios reported that senior Democrats were describing Cooper as a potential “coup” for Schumer, given his popularity during his two terms as governor. 

In Ohio, Schumer also recruited former U.S. Sen. Sherrod Brown. In his interview with The Daily, Schumer said he flew to Columbus twice to persuade Brown to run. Brown won by five points.

Schumer also worked to get candidates in Alaska and Iowa. Schumer recruited former U.S. Rep. Mary Peltola in Alaska and state Rep. Josh Turek in Iowa, The Washington Post reported in January 2026. Peltola was narrowly ahead as of Nov. 6, while Turek won his race by five points. Schumer and his allies pushed for Turek in his successful primary bid instead of a primary rival, state Sen. Zach Wahls.

In Mississippi, Schumer was an early backer of Scott Colom, who is leading in a close and uncalled Senate race. Schumer told The Daily that he invited Colom and his father to his Brooklyn home before he was in the race and urged Colom to run. In a Nov. 5 appearance on MS NOW, Schumer said he had been trying to recruit a candidate in Mississippi for three or four years. Colom initially declined, but Schumer said he told Colom “we’ll back” him.

In several cases, we were unable to confirm that Schumer recruited a winning Democratic candidate, but we also found no evidence that he backed anyone else or stood in the way of their efforts. That’s the case for U.S. Rep. Chris Pappas in New Hampshire, pediatrician Annie Andrews in South Carolina, state Rep. James Talarico in Texas and pastor Adam Hamilton in Kansas. Another winning Democrat, Sen. Jon Ossoff of Georgia, was an incumbent and always had Schumer’s support.

“He’s just a very effective recruiter,” Cohen said of Schumer.

Where did Schumer bet on the wrong horse?

The biggest irritant for many Democratic voters was Schumer’s role in Michigan’s primary. There, Schumer backed Stevens over El-Sayed. El-Sayed won the primary by less than a percentage point, then went on to win the general election by eight points. 

In Minnesota, the primary featured U.S. Rep. Angie Craig, another moderate, and Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan. Schumer did not endorse either candidate, but other establishment Democrats openly or tacitly supported Craig. Flanagan won the primary and had unified party support going into the general election.

Maine was more complicated. Schumer recruited Gov. Janet Mills to challenge Republican Sen. Susan Collins, but Mills struggled and suspended her campaign before the primary and oyster farmer Graham Platner won the nomination. Platner withdrew after sexual assault allegations. After Troy Jackson won the nomination at a party convention, Schumer endorsed him. 

Schumer’s aligned campaign committee, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, supported all the Democratic nominees, regardless of whether they received Schumer’s initial backing.

What do these candidates think of Schumer?

In public, even some of the candidates Schumer backed have not returned the favor when asked whether they would support him as Senate majority leader.

Among the winners who have said on the record that they will not support him for leader are Hamilton of Kansas, Andrews of South Carolina, Jackson of Maine, El-Sayed of Michigan and Flanagan of Minnesota. The winners in three other states — Talarico of Texas, Pappas of New Hampshire and Turek of Iowa — have declined to affirm their support for him when asked.

The majority leader is not chosen by seniority, as Stewart described. The leader is chosen by a secret ballot of the Senate Democratic Caucus. So there’s nothing stopping Democratic senators from choosing someone else.

After the 1994 elections, Senate Democrats elected Tom Daschle of South Dakota minority leader when he was in the bottom half of the caucus’ seniority, said Steven Smith, an Arizona State University political scientist.

There’s also no way of knowing how a senator voted unless they volunteer that information publicly.

“Seniority was never how party leaders are chosen, and it’s been several decades since it was how committee chairs were elevated,” said Donald Wolfensberger, a former senior congressional aide. “Today, party caucuses are king.”

Schumer has been caucus leader since 2017 in both the minority and the majority.

PolitiFact ruling

Stewart said Schumer “fought tooth and nail against half of these” Democrats who won Senate races.

Schumer spearheaded the recruitment of winning candidates in North Carolina, Ohio and Iowa, plus candidates who are leading uncalled races in Alaska and Mississippi. Together, these races would be enough to flip the Senate Democratic.

Schumer initially backed different candidates in Michigan and Maine, but he and his allies supported the eventual nominees. Progressives also disliked his decision not to affirmatively back Flanagan in Minnesota. That’s three candidates that he didn’t back, out of 12 competitive races Democrats won or may win against Republicans or in open seats.

The statement contains an element of truth, because of Schumer’s initial opposition or reluctance to support a few Democrats who eventually won seats. But by ignoring his more numerous efforts to recruit at least five other winning candidates, Stewart gives a different impression. We rate it Mostly False.