NC Supreme Court hears balance-of-power fight between governor, state lawmakers
×

NC Supreme Court hears balance-of-power fight between governor, state lawmakers

Posted: 11/10/2026, 9:02:26 PM

Democratic Gov. Josh Stein and the Republican-led state legislature faced off in the North Carolina Supreme Court on Tuesday, with oral arguments planned in two cases over recent laws stripping power from the governor.

Legislative Republicans have spent more than a decade chipping away at the power of the governor’s office — starting with Republican Gov. Pat McCrory and continuing through the administrations of Democratic Govs. Roy Cooper and Stein.

Cooper and McCrory won several key cases in previous years, leading to the legislature’s actions being overturned as unconstitutional.

On Tuesday attorneys for the Republican-led legislature and their political appointees urged the Supreme Court — which has a 5-2 Republican majority — to overturn those past rulings. Doing so could give the legislature broader authority to go about shuffling duties between the 10 state executive branch offices that make up the Council of State, or eliminating their duties entirely.

The cases being heard Tuesday focus on a wide-ranging 2024 law, passed shortly after that year’s election results were certified. The law stripped power and duties from multiple Democrats who won elections that year including Stein, Attorney General Jeff Jackson and Lt. Gov. Rachel Hunt. For instance, they took Stein’s ability to appoint a majority of members of the state Board of Elections and gave control instead to Republican State Auditor Dave Boliek. Republican lawmakers also took Stein’s ability to appoint a majority of the state Utilities Commission, splitting that power between the legislature and Republican State Treasurer Brad Briner. 

Republicans have said some of the changes were needed to improve public confidence in government. Democrats called it an unconstitutional, politically motivated power-grab.

Multiple lawsuits have since been filed over various parts of that law, including separate challenges over control of the state Highway Patrol, which Stein has already lost; the state Utilities Commission, which is in court Tuesday; and more.

Another separate lawsuit over control of the state control of the state Elections Board isn’t among the cases being heard Tuesday. That case — the most high-profile and contentious of the disputed 2024 power shifts — is still winding its way through the court system.

But the outcome of the cases on Tuesday’s calendar could affect how courts ultimately rule on the elections board case. The legal arguments are similar on both sides.

One of Tuesday’s cases dealt with a new law restricting the governor’s ability to fill judicial vacancies.

Previously if a judge on the state Supreme Court or Court of Appeals died, resigned or was removed from office, the governor would replace that judge with whomever he wanted. The legislature has now restricted the governor to only being allowed to pick from a list of three names provided by whichever political party the former judge belonged to. The state constitution gives the governor the power to fill judicial vacancies; the legislature’s argument is that there’s nothing in the constitution that explicitly says the legislature can’t limit the governor’s choices.

The other case, more relevant to fight over who should control elections in the future, deals with seven state boards and commissions that oversee everything from people’s electrical rates to environmental regulations, building codes and more.

The new GOP majorities on some of those boards and commissions at the center of the lawsuit have defended the changes that have given them power. In briefs to the Supreme Court they acknowledge that the current system violates precedent established by multiple past state Supreme Court rulings.

But while Stein argues that that’s a good reason to strike down the law and return the power to him, the newly Republican-led boards argue that it’s instead a good reason for the current Republican majority on the state Supreme Court to create new rules by striking down that past precedent.

“The Court should overrule them, return the question of how to allocate appointments to statutory boards and commissions to the people and their representatives, and reverse the decisions,” a lawyer for the boards wrote in one recent brief.

Several previous actions targeting the governor have been struck down in court as unconstitutional. In those cases, Republican state lawmakers transferred power from the governor to themselves.

The previous legal losses in efforts to target Cooper and McCrory have caused the legislature to shift strategies. More recently they’ve reassigned powers of the governor’s office to other executive branch offices, each held by Republicans rather than Democrats.

That’s what they did with the elections board, giving control to Republican State Auditor Dave Boliek. They used a similar strategy in stripping the governor of power over the state Utilities Commission, creating a new majority of GOP-controlled seats on that commission, appointed by the legislature or by Republican State Treasurer Brad Briner.

Stein and his lawyers say the act of stripping the governor of power is more important than the specific mechanism through which it’s done. If it’s unconstitutional for top Republican lawmakers to take away power belonging to the governor and give it to themselves, their argument goes, then it should also be unconstitutional for top Republican lawmakers to take away the governor’s power and dole it out to political allies in the executive branch.

Republican lawmakers, however, say that question of “how” makes all the difference. Even if certain powers have historically belonged to the governor for the last century or more, they say, they don’t necessarily have to always belong to the governor and could theoretically be given to anyone in the executive branch.

North Carolina has 10 elected executive offices, known collectively as the Council of State. Currently it’s split between five Republicans and five Democrats. The Republican argument is essentially that any power or duty not explicitly assigned to one of those offices by the state constitution can be transferred to any of the offices, at any time, based purely on the will of the legislature.

“The legislature’s changes … do not violate the separation of powers,” the legislature’s lawyers wrote in one recent brief. “Nor do they reflect an effort to impose what the Governor calls ‘legislative tyranny.’ Instead, they represent a legitimate exercise of the General Assembly’s express and plenary power to organize — and reorganize — state agencies and assign duties among the independently elected constitutional officers who serve on the Council of State.”

Stein counters that if the state’s founding fathers had actually wanted such a system, they would’ve created it instead of writing in the state constitution that “the executive power of the State shall be vested in the Governor.” The governor is the key executive branch official, Stein says, and needs to be able to control state government as voters expect and as the state constitution commands.

“In their view, legislative majorities in the General Assembly may freely select any combination of executive officials to execute any law, not the voters who elect the Governor and Council of State every four years,” Stein’s lawyers wrote in a recent brief. “That is not a plural executive; it is European-style parliamentary government. Our Constitution’s framers were familiar with parliamentary systems and chose to reject them.”

Allowing the legislature to meddle in the power and duties of the executive branch also inherently removes power from the voters of the state, Stein says.

If voters are happy with a politicians’ handling of their duties, or unhappy, then they can express that view at the ballot box and either keep that person in office or replace them. But if the Supreme Court allows the legislature to continue changing around which duties belong to which office after every election, Stein’s lawyers wrote, “voters will lose a chain of democratic accountability to these executive departments.”