300M+ license plates captured across North Carolina: Who keeps officers in check?
×

300M+ license plates captured across North Carolina: Who keeps officers in check?

Posted: 11/9/2026, 8:34:54 PM

Automated license plate readers (ALPRs) captured 319,641,653 license plates across North Carolina during the State Bureau of Investigation’s pilot program, according to the agency.

The SBI’s final report to the state legislature, dated September 24, 2026, shows that the number of plates inevitably accelerated as more readers came online around the beginning of the year.

While officers say these cameras are important investigative tools, some people believe they represent an element of dystopia.

“It’s kind of like setting up a surveillance state. This is not something, we as Americans, signed up for,” Wake County resident Brett Sykes said.

North Carolina law requires agencies who use ALPRs to have an internal policy that addresses regulations and data preservation. The law mentions:

  • Training
    • Acceptable law enforcement purposes
      • Supervisor oversight
        • Annual audits

          WRAL Investigates compared the policies of the nine agencies in Wake County that operate ALPRs: Raleigh, Apex, Wake Forest, Cary, Knightdale, Garner, Fuquay-Varina, Zebulon, and Holly Springs.

          All of those agencies use Flock cameras, with the exception of Holly Springs. The police department there exclusively uses another vendor, Vigilant by Motorola Solutions.

          A spokesperson for Apex did not provide Apex’s written policy but instead pointed WRAL Investigates to its Transparency Portal. 

          They all appear to meet the state mandates. However, written details can be scarce within individual policies, especially when it comes to the search reason and audit expectations.

          Acceptable search reasons

          The law does not explicitly state that a search reason needs to be documented for every inquiry, but that appears to be standard practice.

          Almost every policy requires a search reason. Raleigh and Cary’s written policies do not explicitly mention a search reason.

          Apex’s policy states that all system access requires a valid reason and is stored indefinitely. However, it does not detail what is considered a valid reason.

          Wake Forest, Garner, Fuquay-Varina, Zebulon, and Knightdale all require an incident or case number to be used as the search reason, according to their policies. Knightdale’s policy, specifically, does not recognize computer-aided dispatch (CAD) numbers as acceptable search reasons.

          CAD numbers are typically assigned to calls made into 911 centers.

          “The decision to require a case number instead of a CAD/CFS number was an internal decision,” Knightdale police chief Lawrence Capps wrote in an email. “By requiring a case number, we definitively ensure that our ALPR data is only being accessed for known, legitimate, reported, and documented incidents being actively investigated by our department.”

          WRAL Investigates asked Scott Mourtgos why a dispatch number should, or should not, be considered an allowable search reason.

          Mourtgos is an assistant professor of criminal justice at the University of South Carolina. He said each agency handles the search reason differently based on local context and the reporting systems they use.

          “If there's ever any question about why the search was made, at least we have a starting point to go back to that CAD number and see who was attached to that call, and then we can work backwards from there,” he explained. “If that's all an agency requires, and there's a question about why a search was made, then there's still some work that has to work backwards from that CAD number. Who was attached to the call? Who actually made it? Why did they make it? If it's a question that comes up four, five, six months later, are they even going to remember?”

          Audit frequency

          Raleigh, Wake Forest and Cary’s written policies state that their ALPR systems should be audited at least once a year.

          Some agency policies say they audit more frequently than the annual requirement but don’t specify how often.

          In Garner, the policy states that “periodic audits” will be conducted to review authorized users and the purpose for accessing the system. It also states that its ALPR coordinator will audit every 60 days to review its data sharing practices with other agencies “to determine the suitability of continued sharing”.

          Police departments like Knightdale and Zebulon are required to conduct audits quarterly, according to their policies. Just last week, Zebulon updated its policy to also require another sworn officer, outside of the chief deputy, to conduct secondary annual audits.

          Fuquay-Varina’s policy requires semiannual audits and explicitly notes random audits.

          “Queries which do not contain required information may result in remedial training, restriction of access, and/or disciplinary action for the querying individual,” Zebulon’s policies read.

          Apex uploads public audit reports to its Flock Transparency Portal. In a spreadsheet, it includes the date of each search and the offense type.

          Mourtgos said audit frequency should depend on how often an agency is utilizing the system.

          “If we're looking at an agency that runs thousands and thousands of searches a month, we might expect more auditing at that agency than say, an agency that runs five searches a month,” he said.

          Law enforcement agencies utilizing Flock Safety will soon have to implement an automatic audit tool that will flag abnormal behavior. While agencies can opt into it for now, Flock will require it in January.

          SBI guidance

          The SBI reported 35 participating agencies in the pilot program, with requests to install 340 ALPRs on state roads. However, not all of those agencies had installed cameras by July 1. At the time, 20 of those agencies had installed 176 cameras, according to the SBI’s report.  

          These 20 agencies elected to work with three different vendors: Flock Safety, Leonardo US Cyber and Security Solutions, LLC (ELSAG), and Motorola Solutions (Vigilant).

          The findings, reported to the legislature, are specific to ALPRs on state roadways and do not include data on municipal streets or private property.

          Less than a week before submitting its findings to the state legislature, the SBI sent out guidance on best practices for the ALPR policies to law enforcement agencies.

          “It is an investigative tool that requires strong governance controls to ensure that it is being utilized appropriately by those with access,” the guidance reads.

          The SBI recommends that agencies require a reason for every search and establish strict rules for conducting system searches.

          “A particularly strong practice is to require users to select or enter a search justification and a case number for each search,” the guidance reads.

          Policies should require strict documentation, including the case or event number, investigative purpose, search parameters, user conducting the search and results or action taken from the search.

          Agencies should also consider limiting who has access to certain data by role and require supervisor approval for broad or sensitive searches, according to the guidance.

          The SBI recommends the audits review for excessive searches, searches without cases numbers, searches outside of work hours, and searches involving employees, family members and acquaintances.

          “A review may require questions to be asked of an officer who conducts searches and/or the supervisor to determine the officer’s work schedule, case assignments, and other factors that may help determine whether searches are valid or unjustified,” the guidance reads. “In some instances, additional investigation may be warranted as determined by agency command staff.”

          The annual audit should also include misuse incidents, training compliance and data sharing, according to the SBI’s guidance.

          Multiple agencies, including Zebulon and Wake Forest, updated their policies in the weeks or even days leading up to this story airing. Almost all of the agencies who have ALPRs told WRAL Investigates they either plan to make more changes or are open to making changes to make their policies more specific.