Earls v. Stevens: Inside 2026 NC Supreme Court race, plus other appellate court races
×

Earls v. Stevens: Inside 2026 NC Supreme Court race, plus other appellate court races

Posted: 11/3/2026, 9:01:00 AM

Several of North Carolina’s judicial elections Tuesday could have broad implications for years to come on topics ranging from redistricting to the death penalty, power struggles between the legislature and governor, electricity costs and more.

Democratic Justice Anita Earls is seeking a second eight-year term on the North Carolina Supreme Court. Republican Sarah Stevens, a longtime top member of state legislative leadership, is also seeking the seat.

Three seats on the North Carolina Court of Appeals are also up for election this year. All are currently held by Democrats, and they’re the only remaining Democrats on that lower court. So Republican wins in those races this year could net their party unanimous control over the 15-member Court of Appeals. Those races are:

  • Judge Toby Hampson (D) and challenger George Bell (R)
    • Judge John Arrowood (D) and challenger Michael Byrne (R)
      • Challengers Christine Walczyk (D) and Craig Collins (R)

        The four statewide judicial races, and particularly the state Supreme Court race, put into sharp contrast a frequent dynamic in recent years within the state’s judicial system: When courts have taken up politically contentious cases — such as those dealing with redistricting, or potentially overturning election results, or new laws stripping power away from the governor’s office — Republican judges and justices have almost always sided with the Republican Party’s position while Democratic judges and justices have almost always sided with the Democratic Party’s position.

        Republicans hold a 5-2 majority on the Supreme Court, and Earls' seat is the only one up for election this year. A Stevens victory would shift the balance of power to 6-1, while an Earls victory would retain the status quo.

        And since justices serve lengthy eight-year terms, the results could help shape control of the court for years to come.

        Already looking ahead to 2030, redistricting

        In 2028, three of the state Supreme Court’s five Republican-held seats will be on the ballot, giving Democrats their first chance in years to retake control of the court since they lost it in 2022.

        If Earls wins this year, Democrats could afford to lose one of those 2028 races but still retake the majority. If Stevens wins, Democrats would have no room for error: Republicans would keep the majority unless Democrats could win every seat in 2028.

        And right around the corner is the 2030 Census and subsequent round of redistricting — perhaps the single area where the court can do the most to shape state and national politics. Whoever wins this 2026 race is likely to still be on the court in 2031 or 2032 when the court could be hearing lawsuits over the newest round of redistricting.

        In recent years, Republican majorities on the Supreme Court have allowed the state legislature’s Republican majority to draw political districts leading to lopsided results, whereas Democratic majorities have struck down such maps as being unconstitutionally gerrymandered.

        Multiple seats in Congress have flipped back and forth as a result of the Supreme Court’s rulings on redistricting cases.

        National political groups on both sides of the aisle have spent tens of millions of dollars on the state's Supreme Court races in recent years due to the court's influence over redistricting, and therefore over state and national politics.

        What the candidates say

        Earls and Stevens accuse each other of harboring judicial philosophies incompatible with a respect for the law. But in interviews, each said they believe the court generally should uphold precedent, except in some circumstances where it shouldn’t.

        Earls made a name for herself as a voting rights advocate and civil rights attorney. As a justice she helped overturn laws written by Republican lawmakers on voter photo identification and redistricting, as being discriminatory toward certain types of voters, at least while Democrats held the majority.

        Republicans took control of the court in the 2022 elections and quickly undid those past rulings, opting for a hands-off approach toward the legislature that they say makes the court apolitical, by creating a high bar to rule on any political cases at all. Earls said she has noticed that that philosophy tends to be selectively applied.

        “Whenever the court doesn't want to enforce or protect those rights, they suggest that it's beyond their power,” she told WRAL. “But that's I think that's just a complete misinterpretation of the law.”

        While Earls sees the GOP majority as too often throwing up its figurative hands and saying it simply can’t do anything, Stevens said she had a front row seat, as a member of legislative leadership, watching Earls and other Democrats deem unconstitutional laws she had worked to help pass.

        “When those liberal courts had [the majority], they were simply working on a whim,” Stevens told WRAL.

        Stevens said it’s one of the main reasons she’s running.

        “I'm the constitutional conservative who will follow the Constitution as written, and the laws as written,” she said. “Not as I want them to be.”

        As an example, Stevens praised the Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts’ concurrence in the 2022 Dobbs case that overturned Roe v. Wade and allowed states to pass more restrictive abortion bans. Roberts wrote that his fellow conservatives on the court went too far in fully striking down the nation’s abortion protections, since that wasn’t the legal question that the case presented them.

        Stevens was among the most active supporters of the new state law banning abortions after 12 weeks in North Carolina, which passed in the wake of that Dobbs ruling. However, she said in an interview that from a purely judicial point of view, she thinks Roberts was right to have opposed the way in which the Supreme Court undid Roe v. Wade. That’s the model for how she would rule as a justice, she told WRAL.

        “He said we should have stuck within the question that was asked, and I believe that,” Stevens said. “I believe that's what the court should do: stick within the questions that's asked. Don't use it to create something more.”

        Earls said Stevens simply lacks the legal experience to be able to handle the questions that are asked of the Supreme Court. Stevens used to be a lawyer in Mount Airy, typically handling small-town legal issues such as traffic tickets and divorces, according to state court records. Her ethics filings show that her only income now is from the state legislature.

        “My opponent has been a career politician; she has never argued a case in our court,” Earls said in an interview, adding: “I hope that voters will consider the experience that I bring to the court. And by that I mean not only the fact that I've been on the court for almost eight years now, but also prior to joining the court, I litigated cases in state and federal court” at the trial and appellate levels.