Screen time in schools: Wake students, principals disagree on how to change approach
×

Screen time in schools: Wake students, principals disagree on how to change approach

Posted: 10/27/2026, 9:46:31 PM

Wake students and school leaders disagreed on how or whether to address students' screen time during a panel before the school board Tuesday, as the board and district contemplate whether to stop issuing a laptop or tablet to each student.

The students, who have been advocating for weeks to reduce laptop use in schools, held steady to their opinion, while principals stressed that technology is a part of modern life that students need to be fluent in using.

Wake is dipping its toes into the debate over technology use in schools, which has bubbled up nationally and resulted in restrictions in other North Carolina school districts and major districts nationwide. Parents and some educators have been pushing for more limits on screen time in schools, first pushing for more limits on cellphone use in schools a couple of years ago.

A North Carolina state law, new in 2026, says students cannot access wireless communication devices, which could include laptops, during the school day without express permission from a teacher. Some parents and leaders in places like Chapel Hill, Carrboro and Granville County have said that's not enough because technology is too often used when it doesn't need to be.

It's also a debate schools are having as they can't afford to replace students' laptops, which were funded initially using federal pandemic stimulus dollars. That includes Wake, which plans to use bond funds to replace devices, unless they change their approach.

The district plans to have a new approach to devices, informed by the school board, outlined by December.

'Turning school into daycare'

A group of students who say they are neighbors in Cary has recently organized to speak at two different school board meetings, urging reduced technology use in class. They've organized a petition and told WRAL News that excessive laptop use was hurting their eyesight and learning. Those students comprised the student panel on Tuesday.

The administrators on the panel were the principals of Highcroft Drive Elementary, Banks Road Elementary, Olds Elementary, Mills Park Middle and Green Level High schools. Highcroft Drive Elementary is piloting lower-technology programming this year, with one device available for every two students, rather than one device issued to each student.

Panelists were given their questions ahead of time and had prepared answers, largely not conversing with one another.

Students held fast to paper and pencil rather than using computers unless necessary.

Students are on their computers playing games and not paying attention, they said.

"Technology is turning school into a daycare," said Raj Murthy, a fourth-grader at Highcroft Drive Elementary.

Board members suggested the district try to engage more community members, including more students, given that the students represented Tuesday were neighbors in the same part of western Wake County, who had already banded together to protest technology in schools.

Some families, they noted, might be more glad to have a laptop issued to every student because their family doesn't have a computer at home.

"For some of our kids, devices give them access to the world," said Kristen McCollum, principal of Olds Elementary School in Raleigh.

Principals expressed some different opinions from one another.

Most generally agreed that children need to learn to use technology so that they can be prepared for life after high school, and most said that technology helps teachers differentiate instruction for students at different ability levels. Different learning programs can tailor lessons or activities to students' ability levels.

Catherine Shearin, principal at Highcroft Drive Elementary, mostly cautioned against reliance on technology for teaching. Her school has half as many devices this year as other schools do, and she said her kindergarten through second grade students hardly ever use devices except when they're required to do assessments known as mClass. She's instructed teachers to use physical books as often as possible, such as reading their own book during storytime instead of having students watch another person read a book on YouTube.

"I'm not anti-tech; I'm pro-learning," Shearin said. "A device cannot duplicate a good teacher."

Shearin stressed that research shows that teachers have a strong impact on student learning and that research doesn't show the same effect for technology.

Superintendent Robert Taylor agreed and said the district needs to find the right balance of being modern but also effective based on what works to help students learn.

"I don't want you to go into an elementary school, and there's no technology," Taylor said. "I don't want you to go to an elementary school and technology dominates."

Part of what makes the process tricky is recognizing how quickly technology outdates itself, educators said.

But basic concepts still need to be taught, and some require technology.

When it comes to research, technology is more and more important now, Board Member Jennifer Job said.

"You have to be able to determine a good source versus a bad source in today's society," Job said. You can't do that without a computer.

How often Wake students use laptops

A Wake survey of students, released last week, found that students in higher grade levels can spend about 90 minutes per day on their devices. At the high school level, the most-used app was YouTube. Another survey of educators found that many elementary teachers felt that devices weren't used excessively and weren't a distraction. But middle and high school teachers felt differently, believing devices were used too much and that they were competing against the devices for students' attention.

Still, many teachers weren't sure how they could pull off teaching if their students didn't have their own device issued to them.

In Wake, some school board members have suggested changing or pulling back on technology use in instruction and urged the district to consider not issuing a device to the youngest students.

District leaders have since expressed skepticism that they could reduce device issuance, in part because of some digital textbook and testing requirements, and have listed examples of when technology can enhance a learning experience. Some board members responded to those last week by suggesting those examples --- such as creating virtual trading cards for their favorite story characters --- could be done better without using a computer.

Some board members also said they don't want to prevent students from learning to use technology in a way that prepares them for life after high school.

Textbooks are often produced only digitally now to save publishers money, Taylor said.

Board Vice Chairman Sam Hershey said Tuesday the board couldn't afford to buy physical textbooks anymore, even if they were for sale.