Could election betting skew NC voters’ expectations? New study raises concerns ahead of midterms
×

Could election betting skew NC voters’ expectations? New study raises concerns ahead of midterms

Posted: 10/22/2026, 7:41:49 PM

Election betting markets could shape who North Carolina voters believe will win in November, even if polling suggests a different outcome, according to new research that warns of the potential for manipulation.

The study — funded by the Brennan Center for Justice, a think tank that advocates for expanded voting rights — found that people were 10 to 20 percentage points more likely to believe a candidate would win when betting odds favored that candidate. Researchers warned that large wagers could potentially shift those odds, making a candidate appear more likely to win without any change in actual voter support. The study didn’t establish that such manipulation occurred or that betting odds change how people vote.

The findings come two weeks before the Nov. 3 midterm elections, when voters will decide several competitive races that could help determine control of Congress and the state legislature. More than 1 million voters have already cast their ballot in North Carolina, where voters are selecting a new U.S. senator, all 14 U.S. House seats, all 170 members of the state legislature, a state Supreme Court justice, while also considering three constitutional amendments and hundreds of other local races.

North Carolina law prohibits betting on elections, but prediction markets are regulated under federal law — enabling some in the state to still wager on political outcomes. 

Platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket argue that their contracts are financial products overseen by the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission rather than other types of gambling subject to state restrictions. Prediction markets call their action “trades” rather than bets.

North Carolina lawmakers approved a 6% tax on certain sports-related prediction market trading fees beginning in 2027. The tax doesn’t specifically authorize election betting. Prediction markets offer trades on sports, culture, crypto, commodities, climate, economics, mentions, finance and tech and science, in addition to elections and politics. 

North Carolina legalized online sports betting in 2023 and more than $16 billion has been bet through legal operators in the state since it launched in March 2024. Sports betting operators are now taxed at 23%. Several sportsbook operators have launched their own prediction market sites in the state, too.

How election betting odds could influence voters

Prediction markets allow people to trade on election outcomes, with the odds changing as traders buy and sell contracts. Unlike traditional polls, which measure voter preferences, prediction markets reflect what traders expect to happen, not necessarily which candidates they support. That is billed as a positive by the markets.

“There’s a lot of news out there,” Sara Slane, Kalshi's head of corporate development, told WRAL in August. “There are a lot of social media sources, posts, and I think people are in constant search of wanting the truth. No better way than through the wisdom of the crowds, where you have millions upon millions of people participating in Kalshi that are using their research to buy contracts.”

A candidate given an 80% chance of winning on a betting platform, for example, doesn’t necessarily have the support of 80% of voters. For example, as of Thursday, Democrat Roy Cooper had a 96.2% chance of winning his U.S. Senate race against Republican Michael Whatley (3.8%) on Kalshi’s trading platform. Cooper leads by 9.9 points in the Real Clear Politics polling average, which includes dozens of polls.

To examine whether those odds influence public perceptions, researchers surveyed 1,994 registered voters nationwide on Sept. 21. Participants were shown hypothetical congressional races with both polling results and betting market odds.

When a candidate's betting odds increased from 50% to 67%, respondents were 10 percentage points more likely to believe that candidate would win. When the odds reached 84%, that increase grew to 20 percentage points.

NC congressional candidate fined for betting on her own race

Questions about oversight of election betting markets have already surfaced in North Carolina.

In August, Kalshi fined and suspended Republican congressional candidate Laurie Buckhout after she placed trades on her own election against Democratic U.S. Rep. Don Davis in the state's competitive 1st Congressional District. 

Buckhout was fined about $2,590 and banned from the platform for three years for violating its insider trading rules. Kalshi said Buckhout cooperated with its investigation.

Buckhout told WRAL at the time that she was unaware that the bet violated Kalshi’s policies. "I bet on myself. Literally," Buckhout told WRAL in a statement. "It was a dumb mistake, and as soon as I learned there was an issue, I worked to make it right."

The case doesn’t establish that Buckhout's trades manipulated election odds or influenced voters. It does, however, highlight questions about how prediction markets monitor trading by people directly involved in elections.

The Brennan Center study raised a related concern: Large trades could move betting odds, particularly in smaller races with fewer participants, potentially creating the appearance of growing support for a candidate even when voter preferences have not changed.

Slane, the Kalshi executive, said the company has safeguards to detect insider trading and market manipulation. "We have robust protection, security, surveillance in place to make sure that it isn't happening," she said.

Can voters trust election betting odds?

Despite the influence of betting odds on participants' expectations, the study found relatively little confidence in their accuracy.

Only 19% of respondents believed election prediction markets were accurate, compared with 37% who said the same about traditional polls. 

Researchers also found that warning participants about the risks of prediction markets didn’t significantly reduce the influence of betting odds on their expectations.

Prediction markets also allow trades on the margin of victory in the state’s U.S. Senate race, the number of voters who cast a ballot, the overall voting percentage for each candidate, whether Cooper outperforms his polls and Senate race results in individual counties. Kalshi is taking trades on the winner of competitive U.S. House races in northeastern and western North Carolina.