Wake school board postpones vote on cell tower next to Brassfield Road Elementary
×

Wake school board postpones vote on cell tower next to Brassfield Road Elementary

Posted: 10/21/2026, 12:23:42 AM

The Wake school board voted Tuesday night to table its scheduled discussion and vote on a cell tower project next to a North Raleigh elementary school --- a project that could generate additional revenue for the school district but has drawn concerns from nearby residents about health risks and property values.

The board voted 7-1 to send the proposal back to the school board's facilities committee for further discussion next month. The vote came after the board hear from nearly a dozen people on the matter during public comment, most of whom were opposed to the tower and wanted to see more evaluation of the proposal.

Board Member Wing Ng, who is a physician, said he understood where the science stands now, not showing any connection between cell towers and children's health. But he is more concerned about parents.

"I am not ready to blindly validate or escape any question of the data that's out there," he said. "But I will not usurp the authority of parents to decide what's in the best interest of their children."

Other board members also said they were glad to postpone the issue so they could hear more from community members and ask more questions.

Board Member Toshiba Rice was the only one to vote against postponing it. Board Member Cheryl Caulfield didn't attend the meeting.

The proposal calls for APC-EDGE, a partnership involving Raleigh-based APC Towers, to lease a portion of school property for a tower designed to resemble a pine tree. The company has reduced the proposed tower’s height from 195 feet to 180 feet following discussions with school board members.

Under the proposed agreement, the district would receive $30,000 in rent during the first year, with payments increasing by 3% annually. The initial lease would last 10 years, with options to renew for up to 25 years. The agreement could generate an estimated $1.5 million over its full term.

Before construction could move forward, the company would have up to two years to pursue necessary approvals, with an option to extend that period by another year.

The proposal has prompted opposition from residents who live near Brassfield Road Elementary, including people in the Forest Brook neighborhood.

Residents have questioned the potential health effects of radiofrequency radiation from the tower, as well as its appearance and possible effect on nearby property values.

The American Cancer Society says current research does not support a link between cell towers and cancer. However, concerns about long-term exposure and the project’s impact on the surrounding community have continued to draw attention.

Scott Hubble, vice president of strategic development at APC Towers, told the board during public comment that the data doesn't support a health risk but noted that research on the matter will continue and that the Federal Communications Commission is reviewing existing rules, which haven't been updated in nearly 30 years. The company will comply with whatever any new rules may be, he said.

But the need for cell service is clear, he added.

"Ninety percent of 9-1-1 calls originate over wireless," Hubble said. "We pray one never comes from Brassfield... every second matters."

Several nearby residents, some of them Brassfield parents, urged the school board Tuesday night not to approve the cell tower, citing concerns for their health and property values. They contended cell service in the area was fine or could be resolved another way, with a tower in another location.

"I don't think these families are saying no to better service," said Stephanie Rockwell, a parent of two children at the school. "They want to be involved in the decision and in the conversation."

A high school student, who said her younger sister attends Brassfield Road Elementary, said she wanted the tower at the school to ensure the school was properly served.

"I believe having the proposed cell tower built at the school will give me that confidence," said Caitlin Agresta, who attends Millbrook High Magnet High School.

Agresta said she'd been thankful in the past year with quick law enforcement response to her school when safety issues arose. She said there's no evidence for cell tower radiofrequency radiation causing health issues in children, but there is a risk for emergencies on school campuses.

During a facilities committee discussion on Oct. 13, board members questioned company representatives about the tower’s height, technology, revenue and potential health effects.

APC Towers has said the project would address a gap in wireless coverage and improve connectivity for the surrounding area, including emergency communications.

What the district stands to gain

The district says leasing unused school property for wireless infrastructure can provide additional revenue without relying on tax dollars.

Wake County Public School System already has cell towers on school property, including at Sanderson High School, where the first was installed in 1997. Other facilities are located at school campuses or nearby properties associated with West Lake and Heritage schools.

As part of the Brassfield proposal, APC Towers has also agreed to construct a fire truck access lane on the north side of the school building. District officials have described the improvement as an additional benefit for the campus.

The proposed agreement would allow the company to pursue approvals before exercising the lease and moving forward with construction.

The school board’s eventual vote could determine whether the project advances to that next stage.